After years commanding stadiums as Styx’s guitarist and vocalist, Tommy Shaw’s 1985 solo venture 'What If' reveals his knack for crafting evocative, melodic Rock outside the shadow of his legendary band. On this record, Shaw explores personal narratives and sonic textures, forging an identity that’s both distinct and endearing. The album’s songwriting leans into the optimism and vulnerability that defined mid-’80s Rock, but Shaw’s signature voice and guitar work imbue each track with a sincerity that sets it apart from mere radio fare.
'What If' resonates with listeners who appreciate thoughtful lyrics and strong hooks, balancing introspective ballads with up-tempo anthems. The production—crisp and warm—captures Shaw at a creative crossroads, eager to experiment but grounded in classic songwriting. For collectors, this album is a snapshot of an era when solo projects offered artists a fresh canvas; for fans, it’s a chance to connect with Tommy Shaw’s artistry on a more personal level. If you’re looking for an album that stands as both a time capsule and a still-relevant listen, 'What If' deserves a prominent place in your collection.
Track List:
A1 - Jealousy - 4:43
A2 - Remo's Theme (What If) - 4:22
A3 - Reach For The Bottle - 5:42
A4 - Friendly Advice - 3:26
A5 - This Is Not A Test - 3:26
B1 - See Me Now - 3:42
B2 - True Confessions - 3:26
B3 - Count On You - 6:09
B4 - Nature Of The Beast - 4:06
B5 - Bad Times - 2:44